Millions Of Student Loan Borrowers Catch A Break As Education Dept. Retreats In Major Forgiveness Lawsuit – Financial Freedom Countdown

Millions of student loan borrowers are getting long-awaited relief after the U.S. Department of Education reached a temporary deal with the American Federation of Teachers (AFT) to keep loan forgiveness programs running.

The agreement;  part of an ongoing federal lawsuit, halts denials tied to outdated “financial hardship” rules and ensures eligible borrowers continue receiving debt cancellation under key income-driven repayment plans.

This truce marks a rare pause in a heated legal battle over how the government manages repayment and forgiveness, offering a glimmer of stability to millions still navigating the complex student loan system.

Loan Forgiveness Will Continue; Even as Case Proceeds

Under the agreement, the Education Department will keep processing discharges through the major income-driven repayment plans: Income-Based Repayment (IBR), Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR), and Pay As You Earn (PAYE).

This means borrowers already eligible for cancellation won’t have their relief interrupted by the ongoing court battle. For those who’ve made extra qualifying payments, the Department confirmed they’ll be reimbursed for any overages.

Key Win: “Partial Financial Hardship” Rule on Hold

One of the most significant changes is the Department’s decision to stop denying applications based solely on the outdated “partial financial hardship” requirement. Borrowers who were rejected since July 4, 2025, under that rule will soon be invited to reapply.

The shift marks a victory for the AFT, which argued the standard unfairly penalized borrowers amid inflation and stagnant wages.

Borrowers Protected From Surprise Tax Bills

The Education Department also clarified that it will not issue IRS Form 1099-C for borrowers whose loans are discharged this year, preventing surprise tax bills in 2025.

While final tax treatment decisions still rest with the IRS and Treasury, the clarification adds a layer of reassurance for borrowers worried about being taxed on forgiven debt.

Transparency Mandated Through Six Public Reports

To boost accountability, the Education Department must now release six public status reports over the next several months. Each report will outline application backlogs, denials, approvals, and the number of discharges issued across repayment and forgiveness programs; including the troubled Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) “Buyback” system.

The first report is due within 30 days after the current government shutdown ends.

Court Approval Still Pending — But Borrowers See Immediate Relief

Judge Reggie B. Walton must still sign off on the joint filing, but the temporary framework takes effect immediately.
For borrowers denied after July 4, 2025, because they didn’t meet the hardship definition, this agreement opens a path to reapply; and possibly see their forgiveness reinstated before the year’s end.

Millions Caught in a System That’s Still Evolving

Despite this breakthrough, the larger lawsuit remains unresolved.

The AFT continues to challenge how the Department manages overlapping repayment systems that have confused millions of borrowers for years.
The case could ultimately reshape how income-driven repayment and forgiveness are administered — setting new precedents for future borrowers.

What Borrowers Should Expect Next

The Department’s internal systems are expected to be updated by Winter 2025, at which point rejected borrowers will be notified of their right to reapply.

Until then, the pause on hardship-based denials will stay in effect, and the agency’s upcoming public reports should offer unprecedented visibility into how forgiveness is being handled.

Education Department and Teachers’ Union Reach Temporary Truce

For now, the Education Department’s decision offers short-term relief and long-awaited clarity based on the joint status report filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia by both parties.

Loan forgiveness under IDR programs continues, hardship rules are frozen, and transparency is coming;  but the final outcome of this legal fight could still redefine the student debt landscape in 2026 and beyond.

Like Financial Freedom Countdown content? Be sure to follow us!